The work sampling method has a long history in industrial engineering and management science, and its application in healthcare settings has evolved over time. Originally developed as a tool to analyze work efficiency in industrial settings, work sampling eventually found its way into healthcare as administrators and researchers sought ways to better understand the utilization of healthcare workers, especially caregivers. Below is a brief history of how work sampling has been adapted and used in healthcare settings.
Statistical Theory – The Central Limit Theorem (CLT) (1733-1810)
The Central Limit Theorem is a fundamental concept in probability theory and statistics. It states that, for a large enough sample size, the distribution of the sum (or average) of a random sample will approximate a normal distribution, regardless of the shape of the original population distribution, as long as the data are independent and identically distributed.
The Central Limit Theorem was first formally stated by the French mathematician Pierre-Simon Laplace in 1810. However, its development was a gradual process, and it was influenced by multiple mathematicians over time. The Central Limit Theorem is the science that makes the work sampling method analytically useful. It allows us to make inferences about data sets and calculate the precision of the inference.
It is because of the Central Limit Theorem that we are able to calculate the sample size needed to achieve a given level of precision. We are also able to calculate a number of other statistically important attributes such as confidence and error. The Central Limit Theorem is one of the most important discoveries in statistics and its application is timeless. Indeed, In 1,000 years from now CLT will still be widely utilized and relied upon in research, in operations, and in quality improvement.
Industrial Applications of Work Sampling (1920s-1930s)
Work sampling was popularized by Harold H. Maynard in the early 20th century as a method to study worker productivity in industrial settings. In the 1920s and 1930s, engineers and industrial psychologists were looking for more efficient ways to analyze worker productivity. Time and motion studies, where every action was meticulously recorded, were time-consuming and costly, so Maynard developed the concept of work sampling. This method involved taking random samples of time intervals to estimate how a worker was spending their time across various tasks.
The main advantage was that it reduced the amount of observation required, as only a small fraction of the worker’s time was sampled. This allowed for more efficient data collection and the ability to estimate work behavior across longer periods without exhaustive observation.
Introduction of Work Sampling in Healthcare (1950s-1970s)
In the 1950s and 1970s, healthcare systems began facing increased demand for services amid growing costs and pressure to improve efficiency. During this period, the healthcare industry started to explore methods for improving labor productivity and service delivery. Work sampling was one such method that gained attention.
Nursing and hospital management teams began applying work sampling techniques to measure and improve the utilization of nurses and other healthcare workers. Healthcare administrators were looking for ways to optimize staffing and workflow while maintaining the quality of care. By observing random samples of time, they could estimate how nurses were spending their time—whether it was direct patient care, administrative tasks, or other activities.
Work sampling provided a way to assess the allocation of time and resources without the high costs of traditional time studies, making it an appealing option for hospitals and long-term care facilities looking to improve efficiency without compromising patient care.
In 1956, the Public Health Service of the United States developed a work sampling method to study how nurses spend their time. This study method was implemented at 200 hospitals throughout the US over a 10 year period.
Results from these studies in 1956 showed that nurses spent 24% of their time doing work that could have been done by lower skilled workers. In fact, a review of academic literature shows that nurses working below licensure has been a major concern in the US health system for the last 150 years.
Refinement and Expansion in Healthcare (1980s-1990s)
During the 1980s and 1990s, healthcare systems faced even more significant financial pressures. Hospitals, in particular, were seeking ways to improve operational efficiency to cope with the rise in healthcare costs. Work sampling techniques were refined and expanded during this period, with more sophisticated statistical methods being applied.
Researchers began using work sampling to focus on specific areas such as nursing workload, patient satisfaction, and healthcare worker productivity. For example, work sampling studies were conducted to measure the time spent on tasks like documentation, medication administration, patient assessments, and other caregiving activities.
Furthermore, during this period, the healthcare industry began embracing computerized data collection and management systems. These systems provided a way to automate parts of the work sampling process, improving data accuracy and allowing for faster analysis of results.
Use of Work Sampling in Long-Term Care and Home Healthcare (2000s-Present)
By the early 21st century, work sampling had found applications not only in hospital settings but also in long-term care facilities, nursing homes, and home healthcare environments. As demand for long-term care services increased, especially due to the aging population, there was a growing need for methods to assess how caregivers were utilizing their time and to identify potential inefficiencies in care delivery.
In long-term care, for example, work sampling became a tool for understanding how nursing assistants, therapists, and other caregivers allocated their time across various patient care tasks. Studies used work sampling to evaluate the amount of time spent on direct patient care versus indirect activities, such as documentation, training, and administrative tasks. This data helped administrators identify where changes could be made to optimize caregiver time, improve staffing ratios, and reduce workload stress.
In home healthcare settings, work sampling has been used to examine the time spent by caregivers during home visits. Researchers have analyzed the amount of time caregivers spend on tasks like assisting with activities of daily living, administering medications, and handling logistics such as transportation and communication with other healthcare providers. These studies have highlighted areas for improvement in scheduling, coordination, and staff support.
Transforming Care at the Bedside (TCAB) and Time Study RN (TSRN) (2003-2010)
The Transforming Care at the Bedside (TCAB) project was a pioneering initiative designed to improve the quality of care and work life for healthcare professionals, particularly nurses, in hospital settings. It was launched in 2003 by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF) in collaboration with the Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI), with the goal of redesigning the care delivery process to be more patient-centered, efficient, and supportive of the healthcare workforce.
In 2003, the RWJ/IHI team turned to Rapid Modeling Corporation to develop a methodology to measure caregiver time at the bedside and to support the broad range of continuous improvement opportunities in the nursing environment. Working with the nursing teams in the pilot phase of TCAB, Time Study RN was developed to measure how and where caregivers spend their time.
Time Study RN has evolved through 10 new software releases to become the only standardized tool to measure the impact of change on the quality and capacity of the care giving team.
Time Study RN measures the percentage of time caregivers spend in work activities and summarizes the time spent in direct care, value added care, documentation, meds, non-value added, and over 70 other activities.
The software also captures the percentage of time RN’s spend doing work that could be done by other resources. Time Study RN measures where caregivers spend their time and provides the dataset for evaluating the impact the built environment has on caregiver workload. The data is an indispensable resource in developing functional specifications for architects designing efficient caregiver workspaces and is compatible with Layout-iQ. Time Study RN has become the standard tool of choice for pre-implementation and post-implementation evaluation studies for new technology and changes to nursing practice and policy on caregiver workload.
Time Study RN has been used at over 600 hospitals to measure how nurses spend their time. An example of some of the most interesting studies are as follows:
In 2008, a work sampling study using Time Study RN was completed at 36 hospitals to measure how caregivers spend their time. The study, involving 767 nurses found that over 75% of their time was dedicated to nursing practice. The majority of this time was spent on three main activities: documentation (35.3%; 147.5 minutes), medication administration (17.2%; 72 minutes), and care coordination (20.6%; 86 minutes). Patient care activities took up 19.3% (81 minutes) of their time, while only 7.2% (31 minutes) was used for patient assessment and reading vital signs.
The study identified three key areas for improving nursing efficiency: documentation, medication administration, and care coordination. Enhancements in technology, work processes, and unit organization could significantly improve the use of nurses’ time and the safe delivery of care.
Data aggregated from 668 unit datasets in the Time Study RN National Benchmarking Database includes over 933,491 observations and over 100,000 nurse shifts.
This report shows nurses spend less time in nursing practice compared to the previous study in 1956 and in 2008,
Integration with Other Performance Measurement Tools: Layout-iQ (2010s-Present)
In the last decade, the integration of work sampling with other performance measurement tools has further advanced its use in healthcare. The rise of data analytics, electronic health records (EHR), workflow management systems, and architectural models has allowed healthcare administrators to combine work sampling data with other performance metrics, such as patient outcomes, employee satisfaction, architectural design, and financial performance.
Work sampling in healthcare has also become more focused on specific challenges, such as the efficient use of healthcare workers in response to staffing shortages, patient complexity, and varying care demands. Many hospitals and long-term care facilities now use work sampling as one of several tools to assess caregiver utilization alongside the Time Study RN Natlonal Benchmarking database, staff surveys, and workload modeling.
One of the most exciting use cases is modeling the work sampling data from Time Study RN in an architectural model using Layout-iQ. When imported into Layout, various nursing policies can be tested to determine the most efficient. The following example tests assigning nurses to patients sequentially vs using a geographic model.
Moreover, work sampling in healthcare has increasingly been used as part of continuous improvement initiatives. By regularly collecting and analyzing data, healthcare organizations are able to make ongoing adjustments to staffing models, training programs, operational processes, and lead to more efficient built environments.
Conclusion
The history of work sampling in healthcare traces its roots back to industrial engineering in the early 20th century. Over time, this method evolved to become a key tool for measuring and improving caregiver utilization in healthcare settings, from hospitals to home healthcare. By reducing the costs and time required to conduct comprehensive time studies, work sampling has enabled healthcare administrators to better understand how caregivers allocate their time and identify opportunities for improving workflow and efficiency.
As healthcare continues to face challenges such as increasing demand, rising costs, and the need to optimize resources, work sampling will remain an important tool for ensuring the efficient utilization of caregiver time and improving patient care delivery. Today, tools such as Time Study RN/MD, the Time Study RN National Benchmarking Database, and Layout-iQ will dramatically increase the value of work sampling studies leading to better nurse staffing plans, optimized workspace and unit designs, improved patient outcomes, and safer nursing units.
In part 2, I will cover the methods and benefits of using work sampling for measuring caregiver workload.
References:
1. Towards Quality in Nursing: needs and goals report of the surgeon general’ consultant group on nursing. 1963, Pg 43.; https://archive.org/details/b32174871/page/46/mode/2up
2. Patient Centered Approaches to Nursing. Abdellah, Faye G and Others. The Macmillan Company, New York, 1960, pp205 and unpublished data. https://archive.org/details/patientcentereda0000abde/page/204/mode/2up
3. How to Study Nursing Activities in a Patient Unit. Public Health Service Pub. No. 370. US Government Printing Office, 1954. Pg 50
4. How to Study the Nursing Service of an Outpatient Department. PHS Pub No. 497. 1957
5. Seeing Nursing Activities as They Are. Jessie M. Scott. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF NURSING, Vol. 62, No. 11. November 1962.
6. A 36-hospital time and motion study: how do medical-surgical nurses spend their time?; Ann Hendrich, Marilyn P Chow, Boguslaw A Skierczynski, Zhenqiang Lu; Perm J; 2008 Summer;12(3):25-34. doi: 10.7812/tpp/08-021
7. Value-Added Care: A New Way of Assessing Nursing Staffing Ratios and Workload Variability; Upenieks, Valda V. PhD, RN; Akhavan, Jaleh MHA, RN; Kotlerman, Jenny MS; Esser, Jennifer; Ngo, Myha J.; JONA: The Journal of Nursing Administration 37(5):p 243-252, May 007.
8. Assessing nursing staffing ratios: variability in workload intensity. Policy, politics & nursing practice.; Upenieks VV, Kotlerman J, Akhavan J, Esser J, Ngo MJ.; 8(1):7–19. Epub 2007/05/02. pmid:17470768
9. The Use of the Personal Digital Assistant (PDA) Among Personnel and Students in Health Care: A Review; Anna Lindquist ; Pauline Johansson ; Göran Petersson ; Britt-Inger Saveman ; Gunilla Nilsson; Journal of Medical Internet Research, Vol 10, No 4 (2008): Oct-Dec; https://www.jmir.org/2008/4/e31
10. Work sampling. Assessing nursing efficiency; V V Upenieks; Nurs Manage. 1998 Apr;29(4):27-9
11. Changing How Nurses Spend Their Time; Patricia A. Prescott, Carol Y. Phillips, Judith W. Ryan, Kathleen O. Thompson; https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1547-5069.1991.tb00630.x
12. Mapping nurses’ activities in surgical hospital wards: A time study; W. F. J. M. van den Oetelaar ,H. F. van Stel,W. van Rhenen,R. K. Stellato,W. Grolman; Published: April 24, 2018; https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0191807
13. Measuring the physical demands of work in hospital settings: design and implementation of an ergonomics assessment; Applied Ergonomics; Volume 37, Issue 5, September 2006, Pages 641-658; https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0003687005001274
14. The Impact of Electronic Health Records on Time Efficiency of Physicians and Nurses: A Systematic Review; Lise Poissant, PhD, Jennifer Pereira, MSc, Robyn Tamblyn, PhD, Yuko Kawasumi, MSc; Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, Volume 12, Issue 5, September 2005, Pages 505–516, https://doi.org/10.1197/jamia.M1700; Published: 01 September 2005
15. Transforming Care at the Bedside Project, Time Study for Nurses | Time Study RN